What are your thoughts on a future where code is represented as a structured model, rather than text? Do you think that AI-powered coding assistants benefit from that?

Last Updated: 02.07.2025 11:03

What are your thoughts on a future where code is represented as a structured model, rather than text? Do you think that AI-powered coding assistants benefit from that?

First, it’s worth noting that the “syntax recognition” phase of most compilers already does build a “structured model”, often in what used to be called a “canonical form” (an example of this might be a “pseudo-function tree” where every elementary process description is put into the same form — so both “a + b” and “for i := 1 to x do […]” are rendered as

plus(a, b) for(i, 1, x, […])

/ \ and ⁄ / | \

Yankees Planning To Place Luke Weaver On Injured List - MLB Trade Rumors

A slogan that might help you get past the current fads is:

Another canonical form could be Lisp S-expressions, etc.

It’s important to realize that “modern “AI” doesn’t understand human level meanings any better today (in many cases: worse!). So it is not going to be able to serve as much of a helper in a general coding assistant.

Black Ops 7 - Here Are 58 Screenshots For The Next Call Of Duty - GameSpot

Most coding assistants — with or without “modern “AI” — also do reasoning and manipulation of structures.

NOT DATA … BUT MEANING!

These structures are made precisely to allow programs to “reason” about some parts of lower level meaning, and in many cases to rearrange the structure to preserve meaning but to make the eventual code that is generated more efficient.

Ash Trees in Britain Are Evolving a Resistance to Fungal Disease That was Devastating Woodlands - Good News Network

a b i 1 x []

+ for

in structures, such as:

Bitcoin 'bull pennant' eyes $165K, Pomp scoops up $386M BTC: Hodler’s Digest, June 22 – 28 - Cointelegraph

i.e. “operator like things” at the nodes …

Long ago in the 50s this was even thought of as a kind of “AI” and this association persisted into the 60s. Several Turing Awards were given for progress on this kind of “machine reasoning”.